On Sunday, Galway and Limerick will contest the All-Ireland Senior Hurling Final at Croke Park. 

Some players who take the field will have moved steadily through county development squads, minor and under-20 teams. Others will have been overlooked at an earlier age, developed later or taken a less direct route into senior inter-county hurling. 

New research co-authored by Setanta Head of Athletic Development Rob Mulcahy provides a timely examination of those different journeys. 

Where Did They Go? An Exploratory Study of Player Development Pathways in Gaelic Games tracked 1,841 male players across Clare hurling, Kerry football and Tipperary hurling. 

The study, completed by Rob Mulcahy and Phil Kearney of the University of Limerick, examined how players progressed from underage county teams into senior inter-county competition. 

“What really interested me was the kind of routes and pathways that the players took,” Rob said during a recent appearance on Off the Ball. 

“I probably learned far more about player development than I learned about player identification.” 

The Main Pathway, But Not the Only One 

The research found a clear, dominant route. 

Among the Kerry footballers and Tipperary hurlers who reached senior level, 76% had played for their county at both under-18 and under-21 level. Players who travelled through both grades also tended to make more senior championship appearances than some of those who entered by another route. 

That finding supports the value of sustained involvement within a high-quality county system. Players can build their technical, tactical, physical and psychological capabilities over several years before entering an adult environment. 

The research also identified an important group outside that established route. 

One quarter of the senior footballers and hurlers studied followed an alternative pathway. Some had not represented their county at under-18 level. Others entered later or reached senior level without playing at either underage grade examined. 

Players develop at different rates. Injury, education, competing sports, motivation and access to quality coaching can all shape their progress. An early selection decision may provide one player with valuable opportunities, but non-selection should not become a lasting verdict on another. 

That discovery changed the direction of the research. 

“Trying to find a player at under-13 level is impossible, and we shouldn’t get fixated on that. 

We should look at all the areas that we need to focus on along that player’s journey.” 

When Early Performance Distorts the Picture 

Underage selection has historically rewarded the players capable of exerting the greatest influence at that moment. 

Often, those were the young athletes who had developed physically ahead of their peers. 

“When we looked at players who were selected in the ’80s and ’90s, at under-14 the biggest, strongest and fastest kids were picked. 

They assumed that they were the best because they were performing the best then and there. But three or four years down the line, they may not be the best.” 

Two players born in the same year can be at very different stages of maturation. 

One may already possess greater height, strength and speed. That player can win more collisions, compete more effectively in the air and cover the pitch faster. Another player may have comparable technical ability or game awareness but struggle to display it against substantially larger opponents. 

Those physical differences can narrow or disappear as players move through adolescence. 

The study found that approximately 10% of the under-14 development-squad hurlers examined progressed to make at least one senior championship appearance. 

Players selected on the first under-14 team were generally more likely to progress to later underage grades. However, they were no more likely than second-team players to eventually reach senior inter-county level. 

The result does not suggest that under-14 selection has no value. It shows that ranking players at that age provides limited information about who will eventually perform at senior level. 

“The problem sometimes with youth sport is we get fixated too early and too often on performance. We miss or lose sight of a lot of the stepping stones we need to put in place.” 

Helping Coaches See More 

One practical response is to gather more information about the young athlete rather than judging them through match performance alone. 

Bio-banding can form part of that process. It groups players for selected activities according to biological development rather than relying exclusively on chronological age. 

A later-developing player may receive opportunities to field the ball, carry possession or experience another position when playing against athletes of a similar physical stature. 

An early-developing player may face the opposite challenge. Without the same strength advantage, they must place greater reliance on movement, technical execution, decision-making and problem-solving. 

For Rob, its value extends beyond the activity itself. 

“It’s not a quick fix. It will help the players potentially, but it will also help the coaches view the players a little bit differently.” 

He described it as “a great lens to look at players” and a way to reveal qualities that may be hidden within conventional age-grade games. 

Growth and maturation data can also provide context when performance changes. A player in a rapid growth period may temporarily experience difficulties with coordination or movement. Coaches equipped with that information are less likely to confuse a developmental phase with declining ability. 

The intervention still needs to lead to action. 

“If we can identify and set out a prescription for the player, then we see a big impact from it. But if we do nothing afterwards, we see less of an impact.” 

The Transition to Senior Level 

The later stages of the pathway bring another challenge. 

The study found that approximately one quarter of under-18 players and one third of under-21 players progressed to senior inter-county competition. Under-21 players with previous under-18 experience were also more likely to progress than those entering the pathway at the later grade. 

Underage involvement can therefore matter, but reaching a senior panel is not simply a question of being selected. 

“It can be a considerable jump. 

“It’s not just having the ability to play. It’s having the ability to deal with the demands of the game and the training demands.” 

A young player may be moving into sessions alongside athletes with another five or six years of strength development, conditioning and senior experience. Training can contain more high-speed running, sprint exposure and physical contact, alongside increased tactical work, video analysis and competition for places. 

“It’s not just: can you deal with playing the game on a weekend? It’s: can you deal with all the training that comes before that?” 

This makes gradual exposure important. 

Some young players will be ready to move sooner. Others may need additional time to build their strength, movement capacity, game understanding or psychological readiness. Age alone cannot answer that question. 

“All these factors, you have to be gradually exposed to.” 

Sustainable Structures 

There will always be natural attrition in a county pathway. Senior panels have a limited number of places, and most players selected for underage development squads will never play senior inter-county championship. 

That should not make their experience less valuable. 

Setanta has worked with counties including Galway GAA through Setanta 360, supporting athletic development across hurling and football. The partnership includes coach education alongside input in areas such as sports psychology and nutrition, with a lead coach and wider coaching team working across the programme. 

The emphasis is on building consistent practices that can support players and coaches across several stages of the pathway. That extends beyond preparing the small number who may eventually reach senior inter-county level. 

“We always think we’re developing them to play senior inter-county hurling or football. 

But the reality is that we’re trying to expose them to a really good environment. Hopefully, they stay playing sport and they stay playing in the GAA.” 

A development system supports potential senior players in the step up to higher performance. It can also help to produce knowledgeable, capable athletes who can continue contributing to their clubs and communities. 

The challenge is to keep developing players, keep reassessing them and keep enough doors open for those whose ability becomes clear at a different stage. 

Learn more about Setanta 360 

Listen to the full interview with Rob Mulcahy on Off the Ball here.